Independent Contractors vs. Employees: A Case Study with Gotham's Heroes

Businesses that experience an influx of seasonal work or need specialized skills often look to hire independent contractors rather than employees. But what's the real difference between the two categories, and what are the pros and cons of hiring independent contractors? Let's explore the topic through a fun and relatable example from Gotham City.

Legal GPS Pro

Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.

• ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
• ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
• ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
• ✅ Custom Legal Status Report

Learn more

Bruce Wayne's Hiring Decisions: Robin vs. Catwoman

Imagine Bruce Wayne, also known as Batman, runs a small, private law enforcement agency (with a twist) and is looking for help with the recent crime wave in Gotham City. While out fighting some of Joker's minions, Wayne encounters Tim Drake, an acrobatic and highly skilled martial artist. Wayne offers Drake the opportunity to work together in fighting crime and provides him with further training, a new costume, and a superhero moniker—Robin. Drake is required to show up for regular briefings, is subject to performance evaluations, and must comply with Wayne's "no-kill" policy. In return, Drake is provided with a salary that includes bonuses and raises.

The next night, Wayne is fighting crime alongside Robin when they quickly become outnumbered. Robin is severely injured, and both are backed into an alley, sandwiched between Joker's allies and his girlfriend, Harley Quinn. Suddenly, a cat burglar appears, scratching Harley Quinn's face and dispersing the villains before helping Wayne drag Robin to safety. The burglar introduces herself as Catwoman, and Wayne offers her a job on the spot.

"Okay," she purrs, "I'll work with you for now, but I don't play by anybody else's rules." Catwoman, true to her word, does not show up at every villainous encounter. Instead, she picks her battles, saving her claws for the bloodiest beatdowns, and much to Wayne's chagrin, tends to kill people. He pays her a fixed fee per appearance and retains her for three months, the duration of their contract, after which she goes back to her own activities—including robbing jewelry stores to pay off her student loans.

Who's an Employee, and Who's an Independent Contractor?

In our example, is Robin an independent contractor? Is Catwoman? Are both employees instead? Let's break it down.

Robin: The Employee

Robin is clearly an employee. Here's why:

• Control: Wayne exercises significant control over Robin's work. Robin must attend regular briefings, follow specific orders, and comply with the "no-kill" policy. This is a classic example of employer control over both the what and the how of the work.

• Training and Equipment: Robin receives training and equipment from Batman, including a costume and martial arts instruction. Employers often provide these resources to their employees.

• Ongoing Relationship: Robin's relationship with Wayne is ongoing and indefinite, and he is provided with a salary that includes bonuses—factors that are characteristic of traditional employment.

Catwoman: The Independent Contractor

Catwoman, on the other hand, is an independent contractor. Here's why:

• Control: Catwoman retains full control over how she performs her work. She decides when to show up, what missions to take on, and her methods—which often include lethal force. Wayne only controls the result (helping to fight crime) but has no say in how Catwoman gets the job done.

• Short-Term Contract: Catwoman is retained for a fixed period of three months, after which the relationship ends. Independent contractors are typically hired for a defined project or period.

• No Benefits or Training: Unlike Robin, Catwoman does not receive training or a regular salary. Instead, she is paid a fixed fee per appearance. Additionally, she brings her own skills, expertise, and equipment (e.g., her whip).

The Pros and Cons of Hiring Independent Contractors

Batman, like many employers, has to consider the pros and cons of hiring independent contractors versus employees. Let's explore some of the key points that might apply to both Gotham's crime-fighting needs and your own business.

Pros of Hiring Independent Contractors

1. Cost Savings

Independent contractors do not require the same level of benefits as employees. For Batman, hiring Catwoman meant no need to provide health insurance, paid time off, or contribute to her retirement plan. This can add up to significant savings—as much as 20-30% of payroll costs.

2. Flexibility

Catwoman can be hired for a specific time frame—three months—and is only called upon for major events. This flexibility is ideal for businesses that need extra help during busy seasons or for specific projects. Batman doesn't need Catwoman year-round, but she's invaluable when the situation gets particularly dire.

3. Specialized Skills

Catwoman brings her own unique skills: acrobatics, stealth, and a talent for handling chaotic situations. Independent contractors are often experts in their fields, which means they can hit the ground running without much training. This allowed Batman to save time and focus on crime-fighting, rather than training Catwoman.

Legal GPS Pro

Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.

• ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
• ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
• ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
• ✅ Custom Legal Status Report

Learn more

4. Reduced Liability

Independent contractors are not afforded the same rights as employees. This means Catwoman can't sue Batman for wrongful termination, and he's not liable for providing her with workers' compensation or overtime pay.

Cons of Hiring Independent Contractors

1. Less Control

Batman has limited control over Catwoman's actions—she refuses to follow his "no-kill" policy and doesn't always show up when expected. When hiring an independent contractor, employers cannot dictate how the work is done, only the desired outcome. This lack of control can be challenging when trying to maintain a specific standard.

2. Less Loyalty

Catwoman is not loyal to Batman's cause in the same way Robin is. Her interest ends when her contract does, and she is free to work with (or against) Batman whenever she chooses. Independent contractors often work with multiple clients and may prioritize other projects over yours, leading to inconsistent availability.

3. Risk of Misclassification

If Batman were to treat Catwoman like an employee—requiring her to follow strict schedules, providing her with training, or offering her benefits—he would risk misclassifying her as an employee. This could result in penalties and back taxes. Misclassification is a major risk for employers who blur the lines between contractors and employees.

4. Intellectual Property Concerns

Any work that Catwoman does belongs to her unless otherwise stated in a contract. For example, if she were to design a new piece of technology to fight crime, she would own the rights to it unless Batman had a clear agreement in place. This is a common issue when hiring independent contractors, as employers must ensure they have contracts that address ownership of intellectual property.

Making the Right Choice for Your Business

Robin and Catwoman illustrate the differences between employees and independent contractors in a memorable way. Robin, as an employee, is dedicated, trained, and operates under Batman's full control. Catwoman, as an independent contractor, is flexible, specialized, but unpredictable.

When deciding whether to hire an employee or an independent contractor, consider the following:

1. Control

How much control do you need over the person's work process?

2. Duration

Is this a long-term role or a short-term project?

3. Cost

Are you prepared to handle the additional costs associated with hiring an employee, such as benefits and payroll taxes?

4. Expertise

Do you need a specialist who can start immediately without training?

By weighing these factors, you can decide which type of worker best fits your business needs—just like Batman had to decide how best to handle Gotham's crime wave. Remember, each type of worker brings their own set of advantages and challenges, and choosing the right one can make all the difference for your business's success.

Do I need a business lawyer?

The biggest question now is, "Do I need a business lawyer?” For most businesses and in most cases, you don't need a lawyer to start your business. Instead, many business owners rely on Legal GPS Pro to help with legal issues.

Legal GPS Pro is your All-In-One Legal Toolkit for Businesses. Developed by top startup attorneys, Pro gives you access to 100+ expertly crafted templates including operating agreements, NDAs, and service agreements, and an interactive platform. All designed to protect your company and set it up for lasting success.

Legal GPS Pro

Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.

• ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
• ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
• ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
• ✅ Custom Legal Status Report

Learn more