1 min read
Independent Contractor vs. Employee: Key Differences for Business Owners
Being an employer comes with a lot of responsibilities: there’s the subject of taxes, insurance, training, and a whole range of other obligations to...
7 min read
LegalGPS : Oct. 12, 2024
Drafting an independent contractor agreement is crucial to avoid misclassifying your worker as an employee. A well-structured agreement defines roles clearly and helps prevent legal issues. However, even a solid agreement can fail if you deviate from its terms. For example, if your contract states the contractor can work remotely but you require office visits, this could lead to misclassification. This guide will help you navigate these complexities effectively.
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
Before diving into how to ensure your contractor is treated as a contractor, it’s crucial to understand why this distinction matters. Misclassifying a worker can lead to severe consequences—including back taxes, overtime pay, and fines from multiple government agencies. This misclassification can be a significant financial burden, especially if it involves multiple contractors.
An independent contractor agreement helps show the government the nature of your working relationship and establishes that the worker is a contractor, not an employee. A well-drafted agreement can demonstrate to the IRS and other agencies that the worker is truly a contractor by setting clear boundaries. Additionally, the agreement can be crucial in resolving disputes that might arise, ensuring both you and the contractor are on the same page.
It’s often in the contractor’s interest to be classified as an employee—this way, they could potentially receive employee benefits and reduce their self-employment tax liability. If a worker is classified as an employee, the company shares responsibility for employment taxes, effectively giving the worker a financial advantage.
You might be wondering if a generic contractor agreement template will work or if you need a customized version. The answer depends on your specific situation. Customization is often necessary to achieve your goals. For example, reimbursing a contractor for expenses can potentially indicate an employer-employee relationship, unless the work is in a field where such reimbursement is standard practice, like legal or accounting services.
When drafting an independent contractor agreement, there are some key provisions you should pay close attention to. Below, we go over some of the essential elements that help solidify the contractor relationship, along with actionable tips, sample provisions, and examples:
The preamble sets the stage by identifying the parties involved. It’s important to use terms like "contractor" or "freelancer" and avoid terms such as "employee" or "employer." If the freelancer has their own company, have that entity sign the contract instead of the individual—this can strengthen the case that the worker is a contractor. Also, ensure different addresses are used for the company and the contractor, as using the same address may imply an employment relationship.
Actionable Tip: Always specify the contractor’s legal status (e.g., LLC, sole proprietor) to make it clear they are an independent entity.
Sample Provision:
"This Independent Contractor Agreement (the "Agreement") is entered into as of [DATE] by and between [COMPANY NAME], a [STATE] [ENTITY TYPE], and [CONTRACTOR NAME], a [STATE] [ENTITY TYPE], with offices located at [ADDRESS]."
The recitals outline the background of the contract and the intention of the parties. They should clearly describe the services the contractor will provide. Listing specific, discrete services helps emphasize the independent nature of the work and reduces the likelihood of an employee classification. It’s also beneficial to indicate that the contractor is qualified to perform these services without any training provided by the company.
Actionable Tip: Be as specific as possible about the services provided to avoid any ambiguity.
Sample Provision:
"WHEREAS, the Company desires to obtain services from the Contractor as described in Schedule A; and WHEREAS, the Contractor represents that they are qualified and willing to perform such services under the terms set forth in this Agreement."
In the services provision, you should specify that the contractor is responsible for carrying out the performance of the requested service. Your focus as the company should be on the final result, rather than micromanaging how the contractor gets there. This provision supports the notion that the worker is independent, and you must adhere to this structure in practice.
Actionable Tip: Avoid language that suggests the company will control how the work is performed. Instead, focus on deliverables.
Sample Provision:
"The Contractor shall perform the services as described in Schedule A, using their own methods, without direct supervision or control by the Company."
State that the contractor will use their own equipment and supplies. If you provide the equipment, it could suggest an employment relationship, although there are exceptions depending on the type of work. Whenever possible, make it clear that the contractor is responsible for their own tools.
Actionable Tip: Specify that the contractor is responsible for maintaining their equipment, which further supports independent status.
Sample Provision:
"The Contractor shall provide and maintain, at their own expense, all equipment and supplies necessary to perform the services under this Agreement."
The term of the agreement should be finite. A fixed-term contract or a contract ending upon the completion of a specific project is preferable, as indefinite agreements can be indicative of an employment relationship. It’s also beneficial to specify that the contract terminates upon the completion of the project.
Actionable Tip: Include a clause allowing for contract renewal upon mutual agreement, which reinforces the idea that the contractor is not a permanent employee.
Sample Provision:
"The term of this Agreement shall commence on [DATE] and shall terminate upon the completion of the project described in Schedule A, unless otherwise extended by mutual written consent of both parties."
Specify whether the contractor will be paid hourly or by a fixed fee. Generally, using a fixed fee is better for demonstrating that the contractor is independent, although there are exceptions—for example, attorneys are often paid by the hour, but they are still considered independent contractors. Additionally, include a statement that the contractor is not entitled to any employee benefits or compensation beyond what’s outlined in the agreement.
Actionable Tip: If paying hourly, set a cap on the number of hours to avoid an impression of ongoing, indefinite employment.
Sample Provision:
"As full compensation for the services rendered, the Contractor shall be paid a fixed fee of $[AMOUNT] upon completion of the project. The Contractor shall not be entitled to any additional benefits, including health insurance, vacation pay, or retirement contributions."
This provision should explicitly state that the contractor is and will remain independent from the company. It should also clarify that the contractor is not eligible for employee benefits and is responsible for their own taxes. This helps mitigate the risk of the contractor later claiming employee status.
Actionable Tip: Include language that specifies the contractor’s responsibility for their own insurance and taxes.
Sample Provision:
"The Contractor is an independent contractor and is not an employee of the Company. The Contractor shall be solely responsible for all taxes, insurance, and any other expenses incurred in connection with the services provided."
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
If the contractor will create any intellectual property (IP) for your company, include a provision stating that the company will own the rights to all IP produced under the agreement. Without this, the contractor could argue that they own the IP they create. The enforceability of such clauses can vary by state, so make sure to understand your state’s laws on IP assignments.
Actionable Tip: Clarify whether any pre-existing IP that the contractor brings into the project remains their property.
Sample Provision:
"All deliverables and intellectual property created by the Contractor in connection with the services shall be the sole property of the Company. Any pre-existing intellectual property of the Contractor shall remain their exclusive property."
If the contractor will have access to confidential information, you should include a confidentiality provision. Be specific about what constitutes confidential information—an overly broad definition won’t hold up if challenged. If there’s no confidential information involved, this provision isn’t necessary.
Actionable Tip: Include a non-disclosure period that extends beyond the contract’s termination.
Sample Provision:
"The Contractor agrees to maintain the confidentiality of all proprietary information disclosed during the term of this Agreement and for a period of two years thereafter."
An indemnification clause protects your company from losses that could arise due to the contractor’s work. Essentially, it requires the contractor to cover any damages your company might face due to their actions or negligence. This provision encourages the contractor to take their responsibilities seriously.
Actionable Tip: Include specific examples of situations where indemnification would apply.
Sample Provision:
"The Contractor agrees to indemnify and hold harmless the Company from any claims, liabilities, or damages arising from the Contractor’s negligence, including but not limited to errors in deliverables or third-party claims."
Including an insurance requirement can provide additional protection in case something goes wrong. It ensures that the contractor has the financial means to cover their liability, which helps prevent your company from bearing unexpected costs.
Actionable Tip: Specify the types of insurance required, such as general liability or professional liability.
Sample Provision:
"The Contractor shall maintain general liability insurance in an amount not less than $1,000,000 during the term of this Agreement."
The termination provision should outline under what circumstances the company can end the agreement, and whether the contractor can terminate it. Be careful not to create a provision that resembles at-will employment, which could jeopardize the independent contractor classification.
Actionable Tip: Include a notice period for termination by either party to reinforce the independent nature of the agreement.
Sample Provision:
"Either party may terminate this Agreement with 14 days’ written notice. In the event of termination, the Contractor shall be compensated for all work completed up to the termination date."
Make it clear that the contractor is free to work for other clients, provided there’s no conflict of interest. This helps reinforce the contractor’s independence. However, if you need to prevent the contractor from working for direct competitors, consider including a restriction with a requirement for written consent.
Actionable Tip: Specify that the contractor must disclose any potential conflicts of interest.
Sample Provision:
"The Contractor is free to engage in other business activities, provided that such activities do not conflict with the Contractor’s obligations under this Agreement. The Contractor shall disclose any potential conflicts of interest to the Company."
If you’re concerned about the contractor attempting to hire your employees, consider including a non-solicitation clause. Keep in mind that the length of this restriction should be reasonable (typically one year). Note that some states may not enforce such provisions, so check your local laws.
Actionable Tip: Make sure the non-solicitation clause is clear about which parties are covered (e.g., employees, clients).
Sample Provision:
"During the term of this Agreement and for a period of 12 months following its termination, the Contractor shall not solicit or attempt to hire any employee or client of the Company without prior written consent."
No matter how well you draft your independent contractor agreement, if your practices resemble an employee-employer relationship, the worker may still be classified as an employee. For instance, requiring the contractor to work specific hours, wear a uniform, or follow specific procedures could lead to a reclassification. However, a well-drafted agreement, coupled with practices that respect the contractor’s independence, can significantly improve your chances of maintaining the correct classification and avoiding costly consequences.
The biggest question now is, "Do I need a business lawyer?” For most businesses and in most cases, you don't need a lawyer to start your business. Instead, many business owners rely on Legal GPS Pro to help with legal issues.
Legal GPS Pro is your All-In-One Legal Toolkit for Businesses. Developed by top startup attorneys, Pro gives you access to 100+ expertly crafted templates including operating agreements, NDAs, and service agreements, and an interactive platform. All designed to protect your company and set it up for lasting success.
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
100+ legal templates, guides, and expert advice to protect your business.
Trusted by 1000+ businesses
1 min read
Being an employer comes with a lot of responsibilities: there’s the subject of taxes, insurance, training, and a whole range of other obligations to...
Welcome, entrepreneur friend! In today's world, referrals are becoming even more essential for businesses to expand their client base and increase...
Whether you're a business owner or a consultant, the right consulting agreement can make all the difference. In this comprehensive guide, we'll walk...