State Default Laws for LLCs: What Happens If Your Operating Agreement Is Silent?
When forming an LLC, many business owners assume that their Operating Agreement will cover every key aspect of ownership and decision-making....
10 min read
At some point, an LLC member may decide to leave the business, whether due to retirement, financial reasons, a business dispute, or a new opportunity. However, exiting an LLC is not as simple as walking away—there are legal, financial, and tax implications that must be addressed.
When a member leaves, key questions arise:
- Do they get their initial investment back?
- How is their ownership stake valued?
- Can they sell their share to anyone, or do other members get the first right to buy it?
- What happens if there’s no Operating Agreement in place to guide the process?
The answers depend on what’s written in the LLC’s Operating Agreement and, if the agreement is silent, on default state laws. Without a clear exit strategy, member withdrawals can lead to ownership disputes, financial strain, and potential dissolution of the LLC.
This guide walks through what happens when a member wants to leave an LLC, how to handle the process properly, and the key provisions that should be in an Operating Agreement to ensure a smooth transition.
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
- ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
- ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
- ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
- ✅ Custom Legal Status Report
Understanding the Process of Leaving an LLC
1. Can a Member Just Leave an LLC?
In most states, an LLC member has the right to withdraw from the business, but this doesn’t necessarily mean they can take their investment with them immediately. Whether they receive a buyout, how their exit affects the business, and what obligations they still hold depend largely on what’s outlined in the LLC’s Operating Agreement.
Some agreements require members to give notice before leaving, often 60 to 90 days in advance, to prevent sudden disruptions. Others may include automatic buyout provisions, ensuring that a withdrawing member gets paid for their ownership interest according to a predefined valuation formula. However, if the Operating Agreement is silent on withdrawals, state default laws will apply. In some states, a member can demand immediate compensation for their share, which may put financial pressure on the LLC if there are not enough funds to support the buyout.
Example – How an Operating Agreement Prevents Disruptions
Imagine a three-member LLC where one partner, David, wants to leave. Their agreement specifies that a departing member must give a 90-day notice and that the remaining members have the first right to buy the ownership stake. Because of these provisions, David’s departure doesn’t cause immediate financial instability, and the remaining members can plan accordingly.
Having clear withdrawal rules in the Operating Agreement prevents misunderstandings, ensures smoother transitions, and helps avoid financial strain.
2. Voluntary vs. Involuntary Member Exits
Not every member departure is voluntary. While some owners leave because they choose to retire or pursue other opportunities, others may be removed due to financial, legal, or ethical reasons.
Voluntary Exits: Planning for a Smooth Transition
A voluntary exit happens when a member decides to leave on their own terms, often selling their ownership interest or withdrawing from the business due to personal circumstances. These exits should follow a structured process where the departing member’s stake is properly valued and either purchased by the LLC or other members.
Involuntary Exits: What Happens When a Member Is Forced Out?
An involuntary exit occurs when a member is forced out of the LLC. This can happen if they violate the Operating Agreement, become financially insolvent, or engage in unethical conduct that harms the business. Some agreements include expulsion clauses that allow members to vote out an owner under specific conditions. If such a clause is missing, the LLC may need to take legal action to remove the individual, which can be costly and time-consuming.
Example
Consider a situation where an LLC discovers that one of its members has been involved in fraudulent activities. Because their Operating Agreement includes a clause allowing for the removal of a member engaged in financial misconduct, the remaining members can vote to expel the individual without needing a lawsuit. This provision ensures the LLC is protected from reputational and financial harm.
By defining clear exit conditions, LLCs can safeguard the business from disruptive departures and minimize conflict among remaining members.
Attorney-Drafted LLC Operating Agreement
Get a customizable, attorney-drafted LLC Operating Agreement built for legal protection.
Trusted by 1,000+ businesses to safeguard their LLCs.
How to Handle a Member’s Exit Under an Operating Agreement
1. Notice Requirements for Leaving an LLC
An LLC’s Operating Agreement should clearly outline how much notice a departing member must provide before leaving. Without a structured process, a sudden withdrawal could leave the business in financial disarray or disrupt ongoing operations.
Some agreements require members to provide a formal resignation notice 30 to 90 days in advance. This time frame gives the LLC and remaining members the ability to plan for the transition, whether by adjusting ownership percentages, finding a replacement, or ensuring financial stability.
If the Operating Agreement does not specify a required notice period, state laws will determine whether the member can exit immediately or if approval is required. In many cases, state laws allow members to withdraw at will, which can create unexpected financial and management challenges for the LLC.
Example – Why a Notice Requirement Matters
Consider a three-member LLC where one partner, Sarah, wants to leave. Because their Operating Agreement requires a 60-day written notice and gives remaining members the option to buy out her share, the transition is orderly and planned. Without this provision, Sarah could have walked away without warning, leaving the LLC scrambling to restructure.
2. Buyout & Valuation of the Departing Member’s Interest
When a member leaves, the biggest financial question is: How much is their ownership stake worth? The Operating Agreement should provide a clear valuation formula to determine the buyout amount.
There are several ways to calculate the value of a departing member’s interest:
- Fair Market Value (FMV): An independent appraisal determines the current worth of the LLC.
- Book Value: The company’s net assets are used to calculate the departing member’s stake.
- Pre-Agreed Formula: Some LLCs set a fixed multiple of revenue, earnings, or another valuation metric.
If no valuation method is stated in the agreement, disputes may arise over what the member’s stake is worth and whether they are entitled to a lump-sum payment or installment payouts.
Example – How a Clear Valuation Clause Prevents Disputes
John is a 40% owner in a tech startup LLC. When he decides to leave, the agreement states that ownership interests will be valued at three times the company’s average net income over the past two years. Because this formula was predetermined, the LLC avoids a drawn-out negotiation over pricing.
3. Right of First Refusal (ROFR) for Remaining Members
To prevent outside buyers from taking ownership in an LLC, many Operating Agreements include a Right of First Refusal (ROFR). This clause ensures that when a member decides to sell or leave, their ownership must first be offered to existing LLC members before an external party can purchase it.
Without a ROFR, a departing member could sell their stake to anyone, including a competitor or an individual who does not align with the LLC’s vision. This can create major conflicts among remaining members.
Example – Protecting LLC Ownership with ROFR
A four-member real estate investment LLC includes a ROFR clause stating that if any member leaves, their ownership must first be offered to existing members at the same price and terms offered to an outside buyer. When one member, Emily, decides to leave, the others exercise their right and buy her share, ensuring the LLC remains controlled by the original members.
Key Takeaway: Including a Right of First Refusal clause ensures ownership stays within the LLC and prevents unwanted third parties from gaining control.
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
- ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
- ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
- ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
- ✅ Custom Legal Status Report
Legal and Financial Implications of a Member’s Exit
1. Liability for LLC Debts After Leaving
A common misconception is that once a member leaves an LLC, they are automatically free from any financial obligations. However, depending on the LLC’s structure and the terms outlined in the Operating Agreement, a departing member may still be responsible for debts or liabilities incurred while they were an owner.
If the LLC has outstanding loans, personal guarantees, or unpaid tax obligations, a withdrawing member could remain liable unless a formal release agreement is signed. This is particularly important in smaller LLCs where members personally back business loans.
Example – When a Departing Member is Still Liable for Debts
A three-member LLC takes out a $200,000 business loan, and all members personally guarantee repayment. When one member, Steve, decides to leave, he assumes he is no longer responsible for the debt. However, because the loan was personally guaranteed, the bank still holds him liable for repayment. If the Operating Agreement had included a liability release process, Steve could have been removed from the obligation as part of his exit.
2. Tax Considerations for the Exiting Member
A member’s exit has tax implications that need to be addressed, particularly in LLCs taxed as pass-through entities. When a member sells or withdraws from the LLC, they may owe capital gains tax on any appreciation of their ownership stake.
Additionally, the LLC must update Schedule K-1 filings to reflect changes in ownership, ensuring that income, losses, and deductions are correctly allocated. Failing to properly report a member’s exit can lead to IRS penalties or tax disputes.
Example – Unexpected Tax Consequences for a Departing Member
Sarah owns 25% of an LLC and originally contributed $50,000. When she leaves, her ownership stake is valued at $100,000, meaning she has a taxable gain of $50,000. Because Sarah was unaware of this, she does not set aside money for taxes and is hit with an unexpected tax bill the following year. If the LLC had advised her on tax considerations before the exit, she could have planned accordingly.
3. Filing State Paperwork for Member Withdrawal
Many states require LLCs to file an Amended Articles of Organization or similar paperwork when a member exits. This step is crucial because failing to update state records may result in the departing member still being listed as a legal owner, even though they no longer participate in the business.
Each state has different rules on how withdrawals must be documented, and in some cases, the LLC must publish a formal notice of withdrawal. Keeping these filings up to date ensures the LLC remains compliant and protects both the business and the departing member.
Example – The Risk of Not Updating State Records
A two-member LLC operates for several years before one partner, James, decides to leave. The LLC fails to update its state records, and a year later, the business is sued. Because James is still listed as a member on official filings, he is dragged into the lawsuit even though he has no involvement in the business anymore. Had the LLC properly filed an amendment with the state, James could have been legally protected from liability.
Key Takeaway: Proper paperwork and IRS updates are critical to legally separating a departing member from the LLC’s obligations.
What Happens If There’s No Operating Agreement?
1. Default State Laws for Member Exits
If an LLC doesn’t have an Operating Agreement outlining exit procedures, default state laws will determine what happens when a member leaves. These laws vary by state but often lead to unintended consequences that can disrupt the business.
In some states, a departing member has the right to immediately demand a buyout, which could put financial strain on the LLC. Other states require that if a key member leaves, the LLC must dissolve entirely unless the remaining members agree to continue.
Without a clear agreement in place, members may also disagree on the valuation of the exiting member’s interest, leading to disputes or even legal battles over ownership percentages and payouts.
Example – How State Laws Can Force an LLC to Dissolve
A four-member LLC is operating without an Operating Agreement. When one partner, Lisa, decides to leave, the state’s default law requires that the LLC dissolve unless the remaining members take formal action to continue operations. Because the group wasn’t prepared, the business is temporarily shut down, causing financial loss and disruption. If an Operating Agreement had been in place, it could have prevented the forced dissolution.
2. Potential Disputes Without an Exit Plan
When no formal agreement exists, disagreements over ownership, buyouts, and responsibilities often arise. Departing members may expect a higher payout than the remaining members believe is fair, leading to drawn-out negotiations or lawsuits.
In some cases, the departing member may sell their ownership stake to an outside party without giving the LLC a chance to buy it first. This can introduce new members who may not align with the company’s vision, creating operational conflicts.
Example – Ownership Dispute Due to a Missing Exit Plan
A three-member LLC runs a consulting firm. One member, Tom, decides to leave and sells his share to an outside investor. Because the LLC had no agreement preventing third-party sales, the remaining members are now forced to work with an unfamiliar partner, who begins pushing for major changes they don’t agree with. Had a Right of First Refusal clause been in place, Tom’s stake could have been bought by the existing members, keeping control within the original team.
Key Takeaway: Without an Operating Agreement, an LLC has no control over member exits, which can lead to forced dissolutions, ownership conflicts, and financial instability.
Common Pitfalls & How to Avoid Them
1. No Clear Buyout Formula
When an LLC lacks a defined buyout process, the departing member and remaining members may disagree on the value of the ownership stake. Some members may overestimate their share’s worth, while others may try to undervalue it to reduce payout costs.
Solution: Use a Pre-Defined Valuation Method
The Operating Agreement should include a clear valuation formula, such as:
- Fair Market Value (determined by an independent appraiser).
- Book Value (based on the company’s financial statements).
- A fixed multiple of earnings or revenue.
This ensures a smooth, conflict-free exit process when a member leaves.
Attorney-Drafted LLC Operating Agreement
Get a customizable, attorney-drafted LLC Operating Agreement built for legal protection.
Trusted by 1,000+ businesses to safeguard their LLCs.
2. Ignoring Tax & Debt Liabilities
Departing members may assume they are free from financial obligations once they leave, but in many cases, they may still be responsible for past debts or tax liabilities. If an exit agreement isn’t structured properly, remaining members might also inherit unexpected tax burdens tied to the departing member’s share.
Solution: Require a Formal Release Agreement
Before finalizing an exit, the LLC should draft a formal release agreement that clearly defines:
- Whether the departing member remains liable for existing debts.
- If they owe taxes on gains from their ownership stake sale.
- Whether the LLC must adjust financial obligations before the exit is complete.
3. Allowing Exiting Members to Sell to Outside Parties
If the Operating Agreement doesn’t include a Right of First Refusal, a departing member may sell their stake to an outside investor or even a competitor. This can bring unwanted individuals into the business, creating conflicts and threatening company stability.
Solution: Restrict Ownership Transfers in the Operating Agreement
The agreement should state that remaining members have the first right to purchase any departing member’s stake before it can be sold to an external party. This keeps ownership within the existing group and prevents surprises.
Key Takeaway: By including clear exit provisions, an LLC can avoid valuation disputes, tax surprises, and the risk of unwanted ownership changes.
Conclusion
When an LLC member decides to leave, the process can have major financial, legal, and operational consequences. Without a structured exit plan, businesses risk disputes over payouts, unexpected tax liabilities, and even forced dissolution.
A well-drafted Operating Agreement is the best way to protect the LLC from these risks. It should outline:
- How and when a member can leave the business.
- The method for valuing their ownership stake.
- Whether remaining members have the first right to buy out the departing member.
- What legal and financial obligations remain after exit.
LLCs that fail to plan for member exits leave themselves vulnerable to ownership conflicts, financial instability, and legal challenges. By taking proactive steps now, business owners can ensure smooth transitions whenever a member decides to leave.
Next Step: If your LLC doesn’t have clear exit provisions, check out our customizable LLC Operating Agreement template to prevent future disputes and protect your business.
Do I need a lawyer for an Operating Agreement?
The biggest question now is, "Do I need a lawyer for an Operating Agreement?” For most businesses and in most cases, you don't need a lawyer to start your business. Instead, many business owners rely on Legal GPS Pro to help with legal issues.
Legal GPS Pro is your All-In-One Legal Toolkit for Businesses. Developed by top startup attorneys, Pro gives you access to 100+ expertly crafted templates including operating agreements, NDAs, and service agreements, and an interactive platform. All designed to protect your company and set it up for lasting success.
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
- ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
- ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
- ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
- ✅ Custom Legal Status Report
LLC Ownership Transfer: How to Buy, Sell, or Transfer Membership Interests
At some point, LLC owners may need to transfer their ownership interest—whether by selling to a new member, passing it to an heir, or restructuring...
How to Cover a Member’s Death in an LLC Operating Agreement
The death of an LLC member can create legal, financial, and operational challenges if the Operating Agreement doesn’t clearly outline what happens...