8 min read

LLC Transfer on Death (TOD) vs. Gifting: Which Is Better?

LLC Transfer on Death (TOD) vs. Gifting: Which Is Better?
15:44

LLC owners planning for business succession have several options for transferring ownership to family members or successors. Two common methods are Transfer on Death (TOD) designations and gifting ownership during the owner’s lifetime.

 

13399747_Presentation_1

 

Legal GPS Subscription

Legal GPS Pro

Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.

  • Complete Legal Toolkit
  • 100+ Editable Contracts
  • Affordable Legal Guidance
  • Custom Legal Status Report
Subscribe TodayLearn more

 

A Transfer on Death (TOD) allows the LLC owner to name a beneficiary who will automatically inherit the business upon their death, bypassing probate. Gifting LLC ownership, on the other hand, involves transferring business interest while the owner is still alive, often with tax advantages if structured correctly.

Each method has benefits and drawbacks, depending on the owner’s goals, tax situation, and need for control over the business. This guide breaks down the pros and cons of both approaches to help LLC owners determine the best strategy for their situation.

1. What Is an LLC Transfer on Death (TOD) and How Does It Work?

A Transfer on Death (TOD) designation allows an LLC owner to name a beneficiary who will automatically inherit their ownership interest upon their passing. This transfer occurs outside of probate, meaning the beneficiary gains control of the LLC without court involvement or estate administration delays.

How TOD Works for LLC Ownership

Unlike assets like real estate or bank accounts, not all states allow LLCs to have TOD designations. In states where TOD is permitted, the owner must:

  • Draft a Transfer on Death Agreement specifying who will inherit the LLC interest.
  • Ensure the LLC’s operating agreement allows TOD designations and does not restrict ownership transfers.
  • Update state business filings, if required, to reflect the TOD designation.

Benefits of a TOD for LLC Owners

  • Avoids probate – The ownership transfer is automatic, preventing delays or legal challenges.
  • Maintains control – The owner retains full authority over the LLC while alive, with no impact on daily operations.
  • Simple and cost-effective – TOD designations are easier to implement than setting up a trust or complicated gifting structures.

Drawbacks of TOD for LLC Transfers

  • Limited availability – Some states do not recognize TOD designations for business entities.
  • Conflicts with LLC operating agreements – If the operating agreement does not allow TOD transfers, the designation may be legally invalid.
  • No tax planning benefits – Unlike trusts or structured gifting, TOD does not provide estate tax reductions or lifetime tax advantages.

 

Example – How a TOD Helped One LLC Owner Avoid Probate Delays

Tom, a single-member LLC owner, wanted his daughter to inherit the business after his passing without dealing with probate. Since his state allowed TOD designations for LLCs, he filed a Transfer on Death Agreement, naming his daughter as the beneficiary. When Tom passed away, the LLC ownership immediately transferred to his daughter without probate court involvement.

Had Tom not used a TOD or another estate planning tool, his daughter would have waited months in probate before gaining control of the business, potentially disrupting operations.

2. How Gifting an LLC Interest Works

Gifting LLC ownership involves transferring business interest to a family member or successor while the owner is still alive. Unlike a Transfer on Death (TOD), which takes effect only after death, gifting allows for an immediate transfer of ownership and can offer tax benefits if structured correctly.

How Gifting an LLC Interest Works

An LLC owner can gift full or partial ownership to a family member, business partner, or successor. This can be done in one of three ways:

  1. Outright Gift – The owner immediately transfers their LLC interest without receiving payment.
  2. Gradual Ownership Transfer – The owner gifts small percentages over time, often using the annual gift tax exclusion to avoid tax liabilities.
  3. Gifting Through a Trust – The owner places the LLC in a trust, gradually transferring ownership while maintaining some control.

Each method has different tax and legal implications, so business owners must consider how gifting fits into their overall estate plan.

Tax Considerations When Gifting LLC Ownership

Gifting LLC ownership can trigger gift tax reporting and estate tax planning requirements. The IRS allows individuals to gift up to $18,000 per recipient (2024) without triggering gift tax filing. Anything above this amount counts toward the lifetime gift tax exemption ($13.61 million in 2024).

If the total gifted amount exceeds these limits, the donor may have to file IRS Form 709 and could owe gift taxes. However, strategic gifting—such as transferring LLC shares in small portions each year—can minimize tax exposure.

Advantages of Gifting LLC Ownership

  • Tax savings – Gradual gifting reduces the size of the taxable estate, helping heirs avoid estate taxes.
  • Business continuity – The recipient gains hands-on experience managing the LLC before taking full ownership.
  • Flexibility – The owner can gift partial shares while retaining voting control until a full transfer is complete.

Disadvantages of Gifting LLC Ownership

  • Loss of control – If full ownership is gifted, the original owner no longer has authority over the business.
  • Potential IRS scrutiny – Large gifts require tax filings and may be subject to audits.
  • Financial burden on recipient – If the business is highly valuable, the recipient may face capital gains tax issues if they sell later.

 

🗲

Pro Tip – Why Gifting LLC Ownership Over Time Can Save on Taxes

Instead of gifting full ownership in a single transaction, business owners can transfer small percentages each year under the annual gift tax exclusion. This allows the LLC interest to pass tax-free over time, minimizing both gift and estate tax exposure while ensuring a smooth transition for the next owner.

3. Comparing TOD vs. Gifting: Pros and Cons

Choosing between Transfer on Death (TOD) and gifting LLC ownership depends on factors such as control, tax implications, business continuity, and legal complexity. Both methods allow business owners to transfer ownership to family members or successors, but they operate differently in practice.

Ownership Control

  • TOD: The owner retains full control over the LLC until their death. The transfer only takes effect after they pass away, ensuring they remain the sole decision-maker.
  • Gifting: Ownership is transferred immediately or gradually, meaning the original owner loses some or all control over the business as shares are gifted.

Tax Implications

  • TOD: The LLC interest is transferred as part of the owner’s estate, potentially triggering estate tax liabilities if the total estate value exceeds federal exemption limits.
  • Gifting: Transfers during the owner’s lifetime can help reduce the size of the taxable estate, avoiding large estate tax bills but possibly triggering gift tax reporting if amounts exceed IRS limits.

Business Continuity

  • TOD: The successor inherits ownership instantly upon death, but they may have little experience running the business beforehand.
  • Gifting: The new owner has time to learn and participate in management before taking over, leading to a smoother business transition.

Legal Complexity

  • TOD: Easier to implement where allowed—requires a simple Transfer on Death Agreement but must align with the LLC’s operating agreement to be valid.
  • Gifting: Involves more legal documentation, including IRS filings, possible trust formation, and amendments to the LLC’s operating agreement.

 

Example – Why One Business Owner Chose Gifting Over TOD to Prepare Their Successor

Emma, who owned a successful family restaurant LLC, initially planned to use a TOD to transfer ownership to her son. However, she realized that he lacked the experience to take over overnight. Instead, she gifted him small ownership shares over five years, allowing him to gain business management skills while minimizing tax liabilities. By the time Emma was ready to retire, her son was fully prepared to run the company.

Had Emma relied on TOD, her son would have inherited full control without experience, risking business failure.

4. Which Option Is Best for Your LLC?

Deciding between Transfer on Death (TOD) and gifting LLC ownership depends on your business goals, tax strategy, and succession plan. Each method has its advantages, and in some cases, a combination of both may be the best approach.

When to Choose TOD for LLC Transfers

A Transfer on Death (TOD) designation is a good option for business owners who:

  • Want to retain full control of the LLC during their lifetime.
  • Need a simple and cost-effective way to pass down ownership without probate.
  • Don’t have immediate successors ready to take over but want to name a beneficiary.
  • Prefer to avoid complex tax planning and legal documentation while alive.

However, TOD may not be ideal for business owners who need estate tax reduction strategies or want to involve the successor in business management before their passing.

 

hand building a house made of blocks

 

Legal GPS Subscription

Legal GPS Pro

Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.

  • Complete Legal Toolkit
  • 100+ Editable Contracts
  • Affordable Legal Guidance
  • Custom Legal Status Report
Subscribe TodayLearn more

When to Choose Gifting for LLC Transfers

Gifting LLC ownership is a better fit for business owners who:

  • Want to gradually transition leadership and prepare heirs for ownership.
  • Need to reduce estate taxes by transferring assets before death.
  • Are comfortable giving up some control over the LLC during their lifetime.
  • Prefer to use trusts or structured transfers to optimize tax benefits.

While gifting can offer major tax advantages, it requires careful planning to avoid triggering unnecessary gift taxes or loss of control over the business.

Situations Where a Trust May Be a Better Option

For some LLC owners, neither TOD nor direct gifting is the best option. Instead, placing the LLC into a revocable or irrevocable trust can:

  • Avoid probate while maintaining flexibility over ownership transfers.
  • Reduce estate taxes by removing the LLC from the owner’s taxable estate.
  • Provide clear succession instructions for multiple heirs or business partners.
  • Ensure long-term asset protection against creditors or family disputes.

A trust allows owners to retain some control while setting up a structured transfer plan, making it an ideal option for those with complex business interests.

 

🗲

Pro Tip – Why LLC Owners Should Review Their Estate Plan Before Making a Decision

Before choosing TOD or gifting, LLC owners should review their estate plan, tax situation, and business goals with an attorney. In many cases, a combination of strategies—such as gradual gifting with a TOD backup—can provide the best results.

5. Steps to Implement an LLC TOD or Gifting Plan

Once you've decided whether Transfer on Death (TOD) or gifting is the best option for your LLC, the next step is ensuring that the transfer is legally documented and tax-efficient. A poorly executed transfer can lead to legal disputes, IRS penalties, or even the unintended dissolution of the LLC.

How to Set Up a Transfer on Death (TOD) for Your LLC

In states that allow Transfer on Death (TOD) for LLCs, the process typically involves:

  1. Checking State Laws – Verify that your state permits TOD designations for LLC interests.
  2. Reviewing the LLC Operating Agreement – Ensure that TOD transfers do not conflict with existing ownership transfer rules. If necessary, amend the operating agreement.
  3. Drafting a TOD Agreement – Work with an attorney to create a legally binding document naming the beneficiary and specifying the transfer terms.
  4. Updating State Business Filings – Some states require an official change of ownership form upon the owner's death to recognize the TOD transfer.
  5. Notifying Key Stakeholders – Inform business partners, managers, and financial institutions about the TOD designation to avoid disputes later.

Steps to Gift LLC Ownership Properly

If you choose to gift LLC ownership instead, follow these steps to ensure a smooth transition and avoid tax pitfalls:

  1. Determine the Ownership Percentage to Transfer – Decide whether the transfer will be immediate or gradual. If using a phased approach, structure gifts to stay within the annual gift tax exclusion limit ($18,000 per recipient in 2024).
  2. Update the LLC Operating Agreement – Amend the agreement to reflect the new owner’s role, voting rights, and profit distributions.
  3. File IRS Gift Tax Forms (If Needed) – If the gifted LLC interest exceeds the IRS exclusion limit, file IRS Form 709 (Gift Tax Return) to report the transfer.
  4. Consider Valuation Discounts – If gifting partial ownership, explore options like minority interest or lack-of-marketability discounts to reduce the taxable value.
  5. Sign a Transfer Agreement – A formal document should outline the terms of the gift, ensuring clarity and legal validity.
  6. Notify Banks and Business Partners – Update financial accounts, contracts, and licensing documents to reflect the new ownership structure.

When to Consult an Estate Planning Attorney or Tax Advisor

Both TOD and gifting come with legal and tax considerations that may not be immediately obvious. Consulting with professionals can help:

  • Ensure compliance with IRS regulations to avoid unexpected tax liabilities.
  • Structure the transfer to protect LLC assets from lawsuits or creditor claims.
  • Avoid conflicts with business partners by aligning transfers with the LLC’s operating agreement.

 

Example – The Business Owner Who Avoided Probate and Taxes by Planning Ahead

James, a real estate investor, wanted to pass his LLC to his daughter but also reduce estate taxes. Instead of using TOD alone, he gifted 20% ownership over five years, staying within the IRS annual gift tax exclusion. He also set up a TOD designation for the remaining shares, ensuring that his daughter would automatically inherit full ownership upon his passing without probate delays. This hybrid strategy minimized taxes while ensuring a smooth succession.

Conclusion

Choosing between Transfer on Death (TOD) and gifting LLC ownership depends on your long-term business and estate planning goals.

  • TOD is ideal for business owners who want to retain full control during their lifetime while ensuring a smooth, probate-free transfer after death.
  • Gifting works best for those who want to transfer ownership gradually, reduce estate taxes, and involve the successor in business operations before stepping away.
  • In some cases, combining TOD with a phased gifting strategy can provide both tax advantages and a seamless transition.

Regardless of the method chosen, proper legal documentation, tax planning, and coordination with the LLC operating agreement are essential.

Now is the time to act—review your LLC’s succession plan, update legal documents, and consult an attorney to ensure the best transfer strategy for your business.

Do you need a lawyer for your business?

The biggest question now is, "Do you need a lawyer for your business?” For most businesses and in most cases, you don't need a lawyer to start your business. Instead, many business owners rely on Legal GPS Pro to help with legal issues.

Legal GPS Pro is your All-In-One Legal Toolkit for Businesses. Developed by top startup attorneys, Pro gives you access to 100+ expertly crafted templates including operating agreements, NDAs, and service agreements, and an interactive platform. All designed to protect your company and set it up for lasting success.

 

Legal GPS Subscription

Legal GPS Pro

Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.

  • Complete Legal Toolkit
  • 100+ Editable Contracts
  • Affordable Legal Guidance
  • Custom Legal Status Report
Subscribe TodayLearn more

 

 
Premium Template
Single-use Template
Legal GPS Pro
Unlimited Access, Best Value
  • 📝 LLC Transfer on Death Agreement
  • ✔️ Simple to Use & Fully Editable
  • 📝 100+ Premium Templates, including all Operating Agreements
  • ✔️ Personalized legal checkup for your LLC
Choose Template
Trusted by 1000+ businesses
 
How to Transfer LLC Ownership to Family Members

How to Transfer LLC Ownership to Family Members

Transferring LLC ownership to family members may seem straightforward, but without a clear plan, it can lead to legal complications, tax liabilities,...

Read More
Does an LLC’s Ownership Automatically Transfer to Family Members?

Does an LLC’s Ownership Automatically Transfer to Family Members?

Many LLC owners assume that when they pass away, their business will automatically transfer to their spouse, children, or other family members....

Read More
Can Your LLC Avoid Probate? Here’s How

Can Your LLC Avoid Probate? Here’s How

Many LLC owners assume that their business will automatically pass to their heirs or partners when they die. However, without proper planning, an LLC...

Read More