Implementing Capital Interest and Profits Interest Plans for LLCs

Equity compensation is one of the ways companies provide additional incentives to employees. It can significantly enhance the company’s talent pool, boost employee performance, and increase retention by giving team members a personal stake in the company’s success.

For startups, equity compensation is especially attractive since it allows for compensation without directly using cash—offering ownership shares instead. In this guide, we cover various types of equity compensation for LLCs, including capital interests, profits interests, and options to acquire these interests. We'll also discuss taxation and practical considerations to help you determine the best approach for your business.

Legal GPS Pro

Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.

• ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
• ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
• ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
• ✅ Custom Legal Status Report

Learn more

Types of Equity Compensation Covered

• Capital Interests: Provides an ownership stake in the company’s existing value.

• Profits Interests: Allows an employee to share in future profits without current ownership.

• Options to Acquire Capital Interests: Offers the right to purchase an ownership stake in the future at today’s price.

• Options to Acquire Profits Interests: Offers the right to purchase profits interests, providing flexibility in employee compensation.

If you are an LLC owner looking for a non-cash method to attract and reward employees, these types of equity compensation can be highly effective. Below, we'll discuss the key concepts of capital and profits interests, how they work, and important aspects like vesting and taxation.

Vested or Unrestricted Capital Interest

Vested Interests are ownership stakes that are fully granted to the employee, allowing the ownership to be transferred or retained even if the employee leaves the company. This type of interest is ideal for key employees whose retention is vital to the business. By granting vested interests, companies can create a sense of security and commitment for those employees who are instrumental to long-term success. Vested interests provide full and irrevocable ownership, meaning there isn’t any substantial risk of forfeiture. The only way to divest an employee of ownership is to buy it from them.

Key Benefits of Vested Capital Interest

• Full Ownership: Once vested, the employee has full ownership rights, including the ability to sell or transfer their interest. This is particularly beneficial for employees with a long-term vision and commitment to the company.

• Retention Tool: Employees are more likely to stay with the company if they have a vested interest, as their personal financial success is tied to the company's success. This makes vested interests a great option for companies looking to retain top talent over the long haul.Employees are more likely to stay with the company if they have a vested interest, as their personal financial success is tied to the company's success.

Taxation of Capital Interests

Tax implications are a critical aspect of granting capital interests. Here are key points to consider:

• Tax at Grant: Vested capital interests are generally taxed at the time of grant. Employees are considered LLC members for tax purposes, which may result in significant tax liabilities for the recipient.

• Self-Employment Taxes: Employees who receive capital interests become LLC members, and their income is no longer subject to withholding tax. Instead, they need to set aside funds to pay self-employment taxes on the income they receive, typically on a quarterly basis (April, June, September, January). This makes capital interests less suitable for employees who may not be prepared for proactive tax management.

• Schedule K-1: LLC members must submit a Schedule K-1 for tax reporting. This document shows the member’s share of the LLC’s income, deductions, and credits, which can be complex for employees unfamiliar with LLC tax structures.

• Medicare and Social Security: LLC members must also file a Schedule SE to report Medicare and Social Security obligations. It is important to consider that LLC members are responsible for the entirety of these taxes, unlike regular employees whose employers share the burden. LLC members must also file a Schedule SE to report Medicare and Social Security obligations.

Secure Your Startup’s Future With Employee Ownership

Example: Taxation on Vested Capital Interest

If Elon and Mark were each granted 5% capital interest in Techy LLC, they would each be responsible for paying taxes on their share of the profits, even if no actual distributions were made. For instance, if Techy LLC earns $100 in profit, Elon and Mark must each pay taxes on $5 of self-employment income, even if the $100 is reinvested into the company.

Determining Fair Market Value (FMV)

Fair market value (FMV) is essential for determining the taxable value of the granted interest. There are several methods to calculate FMV:

• Willing Buyer and Seller Test: This method calculates the price a willing buyer would pay and a willing seller would accept in an arm's length transaction.

  • Example: If Mark buys 20% of Techy LLC for $5,000, the FMV of Elon’s 5% interest would be $1,250. This method is ideal when there is a recent transaction involving unrelated parties, which provides a clear indication of value.

• Liquidation Value: The FMV may also be based on the amount the interest holder would receive if the LLC were liquidated at the time of granting.

  • Example: If Techy LLC would have sold for $20,000 when Elon’s 5% was granted, the FMV of Elon’s interest would be $1,000. This approach is useful when the company has a straightforward asset valuation, such as real estate or inventory.

• Value of Services Rendered: The FMV can be pegged to the value of services provided in exchange for the capital interest.

  • Example: If Elon receives 5% instead of $1,500 for half a month's work, the FMV of his interest is $1,500. This method works well when the company wants to compensate for specific contributions or efforts directly.

• Capital Shift: FMV can also be determined by the shift in value from other members to the new member. If existing members each receive less upon liquidation after granting the new interest, the difference represents the FMV.

  • Example: If Mark, Bill, and Steve originally owned Techy LLC equally, and their share values decreased by $500 each to accommodate Elon's new interest, the capital shift indicates Elon’s share is worth $1,500.FMV can also be determined by the shift in value from other members to the new member. If existing members each receive less upon liquidation after granting the new interest, the difference represents the FMV.

Unvested or Restricted Capital Interest

Unvested (Restricted) Capital Interests are subject to conditions and restrictions before full ownership is granted. Employees must fulfill these conditions before the interest fully vests.

• Risk of Forfeiture: If the employee leaves before the vesting period ends or fails to meet other conditions, they forfeit their ownership interest.

• Vesting Period: The vesting period could be based on time (e.g., four years of employment) or performance milestones.

Section 83(b) Election

Employees receiving restricted interests may file a Section 83(b) election to be taxed on the value of the interest at the time of grant rather than when it vests. This can be advantageous if the value of the interest is expected to increase significantly.

• Example: Elon receives a restricted capital interest worth $20 in 2010, which vests in 2016. If he makes an 83(b) election, he pays income tax on $20 in 2010. If he doesn't elect and the value increases to $150 by 2016, he pays tax on the entire $150.

Legal GPS Pro

Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.

• ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
• ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
• ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
• ✅ Custom Legal Status Report

Learn more

Options to Acquire Capital Interests

An option allows an employee to purchase ownership interests at a later date at the current price. Options provide flexibility, and taxes are only applicable when the option is exercised.

• Not Taxable at Grant: The grant of an option is not taxable to either the employee or the LLC.

• Taxable at Exercise: When the employee exercises the option, they must pay tax on the difference between the FMV and the exercise price. The LLC can claim a corresponding deduction.

Profits Interests

Profits Interests give employees a share in future profits without granting them an ownership stake in the current value of the company. Profits interests are often used to provide additional compensation linked to the company's success. This type of interest is particularly attractive for startups or companies with high growth potential, as it allows employees to participate in future success without having an immediate impact on ownership distribution.

When to Choose Profits Interests Over Capital Interests

• Limited Current Value: If your LLC does not have substantial current value but expects significant growth, profits interests allow you to reward employees based on future success rather than diluting current ownership.

• Employee Motivation: Profits interests work well as an incentive for employees who want to share in the company’s growth and prosperity without bearing the tax burden of immediate ownership. It aligns the employee’s success with the future success of the company.

• Future Profits Only: The employee shares in any appreciation after the interest is granted but does not participate in the company’s value at the time of the grant.

Example: Profits Interests vs. Capital Interests

If Elon receives a 5% profits interest in Techy LLC, and the company’s value increases from $3,000 to $4,000, Elon would receive $50 if the company is sold, representing 5% of the increase in value. However, if it were a capital interest, Elon would receive a share of the entire company value, not just the appreciation.

Vested Profits Interest

Once a profits interest vests, the employee is eligible for profit distributions and is considered an LLC member for tax purposes.

• Conversion to Capital Interest: Profits interests can be converted to capital interests under certain conditions, particularly when the employee is allocated a share of existing appreciation.

Taxation of Profits Interests

Profits interests are generally not taxable upon grant if they meet specific requirements under IRS Revenue Procedure 93-27. To qualify:

• The profits interest must be granted in exchange for services.

• The profits interest cannot be related to a predictable income stream.

• The company must not be publicly traded.

Unvested Profits Interests can also qualify for special treatment under IRS Revenue Procedure 2001-43, effectively allowing them to be treated similarly to vested interests without immediate tax liability.

Options to Acquire Profits Interests

Employees may also be granted options to acquire profits interests. These options allow employees to buy profits interests at a later date, based on the value at the time of the grant. As with capital interest options, the grant is not taxable, but taxes may apply when the option is exercised.

When Are Options to Acquire Profits Interests a Good Choice?

• Flexibility for the Company: If the company is unsure about the future growth trajectory or wants to maintain flexibility in how it compensates employees, providing an option to acquire profits interests allows for future alignment of employee compensation with company growth.

• Reducing Immediate Costs: Options do not require immediate outlay from the company or create a tax burden for the employee until exercised. This is particularly helpful for cash-strapped companies looking to defer costs.

Conclusion

Offering equity compensation such as capital interests, profits interests, or options can be a powerful way to reward employees and attract top talent, particularly for startups looking to conserve cash. However, there are many important tax implications, valuation considerations, and legal requirements to navigate. Seeking advice from a qualified attorney or tax advisor can help ensure compliance and maximize the benefits for both the company and its employees.

Do I need a business lawyer?

The biggest question now is, "Do I need a business lawyer?” For most businesses and in most cases, you don't need a lawyer to start your business. Instead, many business owners rely on Legal GPS Pro to help with legal issues.

Legal GPS Pro is your All-In-One Legal Toolkit for Businesses. Developed by top startup attorneys, Pro gives you access to 100+ expertly crafted templates including operating agreements, NDAs, and service agreements, and an interactive platform. All designed to protect your company and set it up for lasting success.

Legal GPS Pro

Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.

• ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
• ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
• ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
• ✅ Custom Legal Status Report

Learn more