The Hidden Risks of Assigning Membership Interest Without a Proper Agreement
Transferring ownership interest in an LLC isn’t as simple as signing over a document or making a verbal agreement. Without a legally binding...
8 min read
Transferring ownership in a Limited Liability Company (LLC) isn’t as simple as handing over shares like in a corporation. LLC members have ownership interest, which is governed by the Operating Agreement and state laws. Without following the proper legal and contractual steps, ownership transfers can lead to disputes, tax complications, or even rejection by existing members.
Ownership transfers typically happen for several reasons:
- A member wants to leave the LLC due to retirement, financial needs, or personal reasons.
- A business sale or restructuring brings in new investors or owners.
- A member passes away, requiring ownership to be transferred to heirs or designated successors.
This guide walks through the legal and financial considerations of transferring LLC ownership interest, from understanding restrictions to drafting an Assignment of Interest Agreement and updating records.
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
- ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
- ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
- ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
- ✅ Custom Legal Status Report
Can an LLC Member Transfer Their Ownership Interest?
Unlike corporations, where shares are freely traded, LLC ownership transfers are more restricted. A member cannot automatically sell or transfer their ownership stake unless the Operating Agreement explicitly allows it.
Membership Interest vs. Business Assets
It's important to clarify that LLC members own an interest in the company, not the company's assets. This means:
- A member can transfer economic rights (profits, losses, and distributions) without necessarily granting the new owner voting or management rights.
- Full membership rights (economic + voting rights) typically require approval from other LLC members.
If the LLC does not have an Operating Agreement, state default laws will determine transferability, often requiring unanimous member approval before a transfer is allowed.
Example – When an LLC Blocks a Member’s Transfer
A three-member LLC operates without a formal Operating Agreement. One member, needing cash, finds an outside buyer willing to purchase their 33% interest in the company. However, the other two members refuse to accept the new owner, arguing that LLC interests are not freely transferable under state law.
Since there was no clear transfer policy in place, the selling member is stuck with their ownership interest unless they negotiate directly with the existing members.
How to Avoid This Issue:
Before attempting an ownership transfer:
- Review the LLC Operating Agreement to check for any transfer restrictions.
- If no agreement exists, consult state law to determine default rules.
- Consider amending the Operating Agreement to allow structured transfers while protecting the interests of remaining members.
Key Steps to Transferring LLC Ownership Interest
Once a member is allowed to transfer their interest, the process should follow a structured approach to ensure the transfer is legally valid and tax-compliant.
Step 1: Review the Operating Agreement & Get Member Consent
The first step is to check whether the Operating Agreement outlines:
- Who can purchase ownership interest (e.g., existing members vs. outside buyers).
- Approval requirements (majority or unanimous vote).
- Valuation methods for determining the selling price.
If the agreement requires member approval, the transferring member must formally notify the LLC and obtain necessary consent before proceeding with the sale.
Step 2: Draft an Assignment of Interest Agreement
A formal Assignment of Interest Agreement documents the terms of the transfer. This contract typically includes:
- The name of the seller (transferor) and buyer (transferee).
- The percentage of ownership being transferred.
- Payment terms (if the sale is for monetary value).
- Voting rights transferability (if allowed).
- Effective date of transfer.
Without a signed agreement, disputes over the transfer’s validity or financial obligations could arise later.
Step 3: Update the LLC’s Records & Notify the State
Once the transfer is complete, the LLC must update its official records to reflect the new ownership structure. This may involve:
- Updating the LLC Operating Agreement to list the new owner.
- Filing an Amendment with the Secretary of State (if state law requires it).
- Notifying the IRS and updating tax documents if ownership changes impact tax classification.
Best Practice:
To avoid legal and tax complications, LLCs should consider working with an attorney or CPA when handling ownership transfers—especially in multi-member LLCs.
Assignment of Membership Interest
Legal GPS templates are drafted by top startup attorneys and are fully customizable🛠️.
Trusted by 1000+ businesses to close secure deals.
Drafting an Assignment of Interest Agreement
The Assignment of Interest Agreement is the legal document that formally transfers ownership from one member to another. Without it, the transfer may not be legally recognized, leading to disputes over financial obligations, voting rights, or tax liability.
What Should Be Included?
A well-drafted agreement ensures both parties understand the terms of the transfer and protects the LLC from unintended ownership complications. It should clearly state:
The names of the transferor and transferee, specifying their current and new ownership status. This prevents confusion about who officially holds the interest after the transfer.
The percentage of ownership being transferred and whether it is a full or partial transfer. Some LLCs allow members to sell only a portion of their stake, while others require all interest to be transferred at once.
The financial terms of the transfer, including whether the interest is being sold for a set price, exchanged for other business assets, or gifted. If the LLC requires valuation, the agreement should reflect the method used to determine the selling price.
The effective date of transfer and whether the new owner will receive immediate membership rights or if there’s a waiting period before they can vote or participate in decision-making.
The agreement should also specify whether the transferee receives voting rights or just an economic interest. In some cases, the selling member may retain voting power even after selling their stake, which can create governance conflicts if not explicitly addressed.
If the Operating Agreement allows for transfer restrictions, the agreement should also state whether the remaining members must approve the transfer and whether they exercised their right to match the buyer’s offer.
Example – A Transfer Agreement That Prevents Future Disputes
A business consultant sells a 25% LLC stake to an outside investor. The agreement only specifies the sale price but does not clarify whether the investor gains voting rights. A few months later, the new member insists on participating in LLC management decisions, while existing members argue that voting rights were never included.
To avoid these types of disputes, the agreement should have explicitly defined the extent of the transferee’s ownership privileges, ensuring all parties understood the terms before finalizing the transaction.
How to Ensure the Agreement is Enforceable
For the Assignment of Interest Agreement to be legally binding, it should be signed and notarized by both parties. If the transfer involves a large financial transaction, having an attorney draft or review the document adds an extra layer of protection for both the selling and purchasing parties.
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
- ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
- ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
- ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
- ✅ Custom Legal Status Report
Updating State & IRS Records After an Ownership Transfer
Once the ownership transfer is complete, the LLC must update its records and notify the appropriate agencies to reflect the new ownership structure. Failure to do so can create legal and tax complications, as the government may still hold the selling member liable for the LLC’s obligations.
State Filing Requirements
Many states require LLCs to file an amendment to their Articles of Organization when a member leaves or joins the company. This filing typically updates:
- The LLC’s official ownership records.
- The names and addresses of current members on file with the state.
- The LLC’s registered agent, if the ownership change affects representation.
Some states have specific deadlines for reporting ownership changes, and failing to update state records on time can lead to penalties.
Do You Need a New EIN?
For single-member LLCs that change owners, the IRS may require a new Employer Identification Number (EIN). Multi-member LLCs usually do not need a new EIN unless the ownership change alters the LLC’s tax classification (e.g., a multi-member LLC becoming a single-member LLC).
If the LLC is taxed as an S-Corp or Partnership, an ownership change may require new tax elections or modifications to the company’s operating structure.
Example – How a Member’s Exit Created Tax Issues
A two-member LLC had an equal 50/50 split in ownership. One member left and transferred their entire interest to the remaining owner, effectively making the LLC a single-member LLC. However, the remaining member failed to notify the IRS, and the LLC continued to be taxed as a partnership.
Months later, the IRS audited the company, resulting in misfiled tax returns and penalties because the LLC’s tax classification had changed without proper documentation.
How to Avoid This Issue:
Once an ownership transfer is complete, LLCs should:
- Update their Articles of Organization with the state.
- Amend their Operating Agreement to reflect new ownership percentages.
- Notify the IRS of any changes that could affect tax status.
- Consult a tax professional to determine if a new EIN or tax election is needed.
Special Considerations: Partial vs. Full Ownership Transfers
Not all LLC ownership transfers look the same. Some members sell only a portion of their interest, while others exit the company completely. Each scenario requires a different approach, and failing to plan for these variations can cause unexpected conflicts among members.
Partial Transfers: Selling a Portion of Ownership
A partial transfer occurs when a member sells or gifts part of their ownership interest but remains involved in the LLC. This type of transfer can be beneficial when an owner wants to bring in a new partner or raise capital while still maintaining control.
However, partial transfers can create management issues if not properly documented. The new owner may expect decision-making rights, while the remaining members might assume they’re only entitled to a share of profits.
Example – A Partial Transfer That Created a Governance Dispute
A real estate investment LLC has three equal members. One member decides to sell 15% of their ownership to an outside investor but fails to specify whether the investor gets voting rights.
Months later, the investor demands a seat at management meetings, arguing that ownership should come with decision-making power. The remaining members, however, insist that they never agreed to a new voting partner.
Since the contract did not define voting rights, the members must now resolve the issue through negotiation—or worse, legal action.
How to Avoid This Issue:
Before approving a partial transfer, LLCs should:
- Update the Operating Agreement to specify whether the new owner receives voting rights.
- Clarify the transferee’s role in company decisions and financial distributions.
- Ensure all members agree to the transfer’s terms before finalizing the sale.
Full Transfers: When a Member Completely Exits the LLC
A full ownership transfer happens when a member sells 100% of their interest and permanently exits the LLC. While this seems straightforward, complications arise if the remaining members don’t want the new buyer or if the LLC has strict transfer restrictions.
For example, some LLCs require that existing members get the first opportunity to buy the departing member’s interest before selling to an outside party. This is known as a Right of First Refusal (ROFR) clause.
If the Operating Agreement doesn’t include ROFR protections, a departing member could sell their interest to an outsider who has different goals or expectations, creating conflict among the remaining owners.
Example – A Full Transfer That Led to Ownership Conflict
An LLC with four equal members has no restrictions on ownership transfers. One member sells their entire 25% stake to an outside buyer without consulting the group. The new owner immediately tries to change the LLC’s business strategy, leading to internal disagreements.
The remaining members, frustrated that they had no say in the new ownership, seek legal action to block the buyer from participating in management decisions.
How to Avoid This Issue:
To prevent similar conflicts, LLCs should:
- Include a Right of First Refusal (ROFR) clause in the Operating Agreement.
- Require member approval before allowing outside buyers to enter the LLC.
- Set clear expectations on how full transfers affect decision-making rights.
Conclusion: Protecting Your LLC from Ownership Transfer Disputes
Transferring LLC ownership is more complex than simply selling shares—it requires careful legal planning, proper documentation, and compliance with state laws. Whether transferring a small portion of interest or a full exit sale, LLC members must ensure that:
- The Operating Agreement outlines clear transfer rules.
- An Assignment of Interest Agreement is properly drafted.
- State and IRS records are updated to reflect new ownership.
Ignoring these steps can lead to disputes, financial liabilities, and potential tax penalties. By proactively planning for ownership changes, LLCs can protect their business and ensure a smooth transition when a member decides to transfer their stake.
Next Step: Download our Assignment of Interest Agreement template to simplify your LLC ownership transfer process.
Do I need a lawyer for my business?
The biggest question now is, "Do I need a lawyer for this?” For most businesses and in most cases, you might not need a lawyer for simple contract issues. Instead, many business owners rely on Legal GPS Pro to help with their legal needs.
Legal GPS Pro is your All-In-One Legal Toolkit for Businesses. Developed by top startup attorneys, Pro gives you access to 100+ expertly crafted templates including operating agreements, NDAs, and service agreements, and an interactive platform. All designed to protect your company and set it up for lasting success.
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
- ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
- ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
- ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
- ✅ Custom Legal Status Report
LLC Membership Interest vs. Ownership Transfer: Key Differences and Why They Matter
Transferring ownership in an LLC isn’t as straightforward as selling stock in a corporation. LLCs have a unique ownership structure, and before...
How to Sell Your LLC Ownership Stake Without Legal Hassles
Selling your LLC ownership stake might seem straightforward—find a buyer, take the money, and walk away. But in reality, the process involves legal,...